
At 7.35pm on 7th September 1987 I tuned in to watch the first part of a new series of Doctor Who. The story Time and the Rani wasn't just a series opener but the first appearance of a new actor in the lead role. Although not keen at first I warmed to the sixth Doctor, but the entire series in which he had been on trial mainly tried my patience. I stuck with it though, because the magic that had kept me hooked since Tom Baker first put a spell on me was still there.
Why was it on a Monday rather than a Saturday? What have they done to the theme music? How could the new title sequence look so dodgy? Did the Doctor just give a cheeky wink at the end of it? What the hell was that regeneration scene? The Rani was back again? Why was the new Doctor pratting about so much? Why was it all so cringeworthy? Why did it all seem so childish?I had left school that summer, certain in the fact that I had flunked my A-levels. Whilst trying to figure out what I was going to do next I looked for a summer job and somehow ended up working in London for a bank I'd barely heard of. I wore suits now, not a school uniform. I started using the filofax given to me as a joke gift that Christmas, or pretended to at least. I shopped in Tie Rack for goodness sake. I was now an adult. Suddenly Doctor Who seemed very much a kid's show. And I was no longer a kid. The following week I was nowhere near a TV. I was either at the pub after work or in my bedroom listening to Sting's latest solo album. I had outgrown my favourite show. I had given up on Doctor Who.
Fastforward 23 years and, like many, I'm awaiting the arrival of Matt Smith's first series having taken up the sonic baton from David Tennant at the end of the Christmas special. I'd been dipping into some Who forums and noticed that one era appeared to polarise fans more than any other. That of Sylvester McCoy's. Some of the stories discussed intrigued me. And apparently McCoy's tenure improved, particularly his third series.
Had I given up too quickly and too easily back in the day? Should I have afforded McCoy more of a chance? I'd re-watched a few classic serials by that point, my brother and I regularly gifting each other DVDs of stories from the Tom Baker era, and the odd one here and there from earlier and later Doctors. Would I actually give a seventh Doctor story a go? I took the plunge and selected two stories from season 26.
Unfortunately Battlefield made it to the DVD player first, and it merely told me that perhaps deciding to stop watching in '87 was for the best. The special features were enjoyable though, to the degree that I resolved to watch the extras on the other DVD, Ghost Light, even if I didn't bother watching the actual serial. I enjoyed the features so much that the story went on straight after. Ghost Light had an intriguing plot, fabulous Victorian sets, atmospheric music, McCoy was decent and the supporting cast was stellar. This was more like it.
The Curse of Fenric and Survival were snapped up next. This time the serials were viewed first and then the special features, which I found as entertaining as the stories. Season 26 all watched I backed up to the 25th anniversary year and ordered Remembrance of the Daleks. Such was the craving by this point that I even bought the DVD of a serial from 1987, the season 24 story Delta and the Bannermen, which was worth it for the line "get the hatchling safely to the Brood planet" alone.
Frustratingly this was all the McCoy serials released on DVD at that point. Only six of his twelve stories. There was nothing else for it, some would have to be tracked down on trusty old VHS. I plumbed for two that had provoked the most division on the forums: The Happiness Patrol and the infamous Paradise Towers.
Neither story disappointed. Broadcast at the height of the Acid House craze of 1988, The Happiness Patrol's Bertie Basset-esque Kandy Man must have freaked out any ravers who happened to witness his few moments of TV gold at the time. A bad trip of a villain, my favourite moment is when he casually picks up the phone and answers "Hello" in that psychotic helium rasp.
It was odd watching these knowing that there were no extras to dip into immediately afterwards. I would just have to enjoy the stories for now and wait for the DVD release, however sooner or later that would be. An element of the experience was missing though. I wanted the story behind the story. Without that it felt incomplete.
The next DVD to be released later that year was none other than Time and The Rani. Would I actually spend money on the story that had caused me to ditch my childhood favourite almost a quarter of a century before? To help me decide a couple more serials were procured on VHS. Enjoyable but muddled, Dragonfire and Silver Nemesis didn't exactly help the cause but the latter came with a lengthy 'making of' extra which I devoured. When Time and The Rani was released on DVD nearly quarter of a century since it was originally broadcast I couldn't help myself. In fact I pre-ordered and watched the first episode as soon as it arrived through the letterbox.
The McCoy era title sequence had grown on me, though maybe not the wink. The arrangement of the theme music now had a curious appeal. The regeneration scene was still awful, but understandable given the situation off camera. The Rani... why haven't they brought her back? The Doctor was still pratting about too much, but he was likable. It was still cringeworthy and childish in parts, but not without its charm.
Then, some 23 years since watching part one, I watched part two of Time and The Rani.
What was this new-found appreciation? How did it come about, this bizarre nostalgia for television that I didn't actually see at the time? For the show I should have continued watching but hadn't? Because I had felt too 'adult' (I really wasn't). Was it because I had a better understanding of what went into making it? Was it because I now had a fuller idea of the drama that went on behind the scenes? The insufficient budgets and the time constraints. The creative differences and the contemptuous controller. Was it because I had a grasp of what they were trying to achieve, and of how these limitations often resulted in the end result being less than what they and the viewer had hoped for?
The extras really were the key. These are what compelled me to repurchase on DVD stories which I had only recently gathered on VHS. Even the supposed nadir of classic Who: Paradise Towers. Primarily so I could watch the special features rather than the actual serial again.
In 2012 The Greatest Show In The Galaxy was the last McCoy serial to get a DVD release. I had managed to resist buying the VHS of this one, mainly because stories involving clowns and circuses don't usually hold much appeal for me. But this story was referenced in so many of the extras on the other DVDs that in the end I had to get it. And of course fully savoured the complete experience that was the last of the McCoys on DVD.
My nostalgia was as much for the production of the programme as the show itself. Partly because I've held long-time aspirations to write for the screen. The thing is, as much as I want to work in the industry in the present, the dream is to work on Doctor Who in the late 1980s. The obstacle being I'd need a TARDIS to even be in with a chance of that. So, for now, a plethora of special features will just have to do ;-)
*****************************************************
The McCoy era's troubled production is entertainingly chronicled by Script Editor Andrew Cartmel in his memoir Script Doctor: The Inside Story of Doctor Who 1986-1989